Fans, we need your help. Please send in missing title reigns, locations, dates and/or notes if you have them.
| WON BY | LOCATION | DATE | NOTES |
| … | |||
| Mr. Bibbs | |||
| William Gaylord | Saint Louis, Mo. | 1/15/05 | |
| Phil E. Blunt | Saint Louis, Mo. | 7/9/05 | |
| Moondog Rover | Saint Louis, Mo. | 5/13/06 | |
| Lumberjack Gabe | Saint Louis, Mo. | 3/15/08 | |
| The Big Texan | Saint Louis, Mo. | 9/6/08 | |
| Brandon Espinosa | Saint Louis, Mo. | 5/8/10 | |
| Gary Jackson | Saint Louis, Mo. | 11/6/10 | |
| VACANT | 12/4/10 | Jackson had to vacate one title | |
| Johnny Courageous | Saint Louis, Mo. | 12/4/10 | |
| Dave Vaughn | Saint Louis, Mo. | 7/9/11 | |
| Big Dave Osborne | Saint Louis, Mo. | 1/21/12 | |
| Chase King | Saint Louis, Mo. | 12/8/12 | Osborne didn’t participate |
| Matt King | Saint Louis, Mo. | 5/11/13 |
Credit: Patrick Brandmeyer
