Fans, we need your help. Please send in missing title reigns, locations, dates and/or notes if you have them.
| WON BY | LOCATION | DATE | NOTES |
| Ron Brewer & Tim Kierns | May-85 | ||
| Rob Phillips & Ed Lewis | Sep-85 | ||
| Gary Jackson & Stan Hurley | Oct-85 | ||
| Rob Phillips & Ed Smith | Aug-86 | ||
| Gary Jackson & John Phillips | Mar-87 | ||
| Tony Casta & Ed Smith | Jun-88 | ||
| Freedom Rider & Ghetto Grubbs | Sep-88 | ||
| Chaz Wesson & Chris Giacin | Feb-89 | ||
| Freedom Rider & Ghetto Grubbs | Jun-90 | ||
| Chaz Wesson & Keith Smith | Sep-91 | ||
| Rick Brewer & Jeff Hawkins | Mar-92 | ||
| Keith Smith & Chris Cody | Oct-92 | ||
| Rick Brewer & Jeff Hawkins | Dec-92 | ||
| Freedom Rider & Ghetto Grubbs | May-93 | ||
| … | |||
| Frankie D & Gambler | Apr-96 | ||
| … | |||
| VACANT | Feb-97 | ||
| Chaz Wesson & Keith Smith | Saint Louis, Mo. | 2/15/97 | def. Giant Assassin & John Blackheart |
| John Blackheart & Billy Diamond | 1997 | ||
| Lumberjacks Abe & Gabe | 1998 | ||
| … | |||
| VACANT | |||
| Shaft & Phil E. Blunt | Saint Louis, Mo. | 11/5/05 | def. Lumberjacks |
| Shaft & Gary Jackson | Saint Louis, Mo. | 10/7/06 | Shaft def. Blunt to choose new partner |
| Phil E. Blunt & Jerome Cody | Saint Louis, Mo. | 2/24/07 | |
| Mr. Bibbs & Dave Vaughn | Saint Louis, Mo. | 1/3/08 | |
| Lumberjacks Abe & Gabe | Saint Louis, Mo. | 8/9/08 | Shaft subbed for Bibbs |
| The Big Texan & Waco | East Carondelet, Ill. | 10/24/09 | cage match |
| Lumberjacks Abe & Gabe | Saint Louis, Mo. | 6/12/10 | |
| The Big Texan & Tony Raze | Saint Louis, Mo. | 5/14/11 | |
| Lumberjacks Abe & Gabe | Saint Louis, Mo. | 10/29/11 | |
| LaMarcus Clinton & Chase King | Saint Louis, Mo. | 6/9/12 |
Credit: Patrick Brandmeyer, Gary Weiss
