| WON BY | LOCATION | DATE | NOTES |
| Gary Jackson | Saint Louis, Mo. | 12/4/10 | def. Donovan Ruddick |
| Dave Vaughn | Saint Louis, Mo. | 3/12/11 | |
| Brandon Espinosa | Saint Louis, Mo. | 6/11/11 | |
| VACANT | 2/11/12 | Espinosa holds heavyweight title | |
| Chase King | Saint Louis, Mo. | 2/11/12 | def. Max Archer |
| Dave Vaughn | Saint Louis, Mo. | 5/12/12 | |
| VACANT | 2/16/13 | Vaughn leaves promotion | |
| Jimmy D | Saint Louis, Mo. | 2/16/13 | def. A.J. Williams |
| Brian James | Saint Louis, Mo. | 5/11/13 | no disqualification match |
