Before 2011, SICW promoter Herb Simmons rarely had any championships exclusive to his company. A tag team championship was sanctioned at least in 1992, but nothing else is known.
On August 17, 2019, SICW rebooted its promotion-exclusive tag team championship when The Professionals (Shawn Santel & Mauler McDarby) faced the Coffin Club (Sean Vincent & Kahyman).
Fans, we need your help. Please send in missing title reigns, locations, dates and/or notes if you have them.
| WON BY | LOCATION | DATE | NOTES |
| Shark & Steve Stingray | Jun-92 | ||
| … | |||
| VACANT | ≤2005 | probably abandoned much earlier in favor of MMWA tag title | |
| Shawn Santel & Mauler McDarby | East Carondelet, Ill. | 8/17/19 | def. Kahyman & Sean Vincent for inaugural title |
| Gary Jackson & Gil Rogers | East Carondelet, Ill. | 12/28/19 | |
| Ken Kasa & Christopher Hargas | East Carondelet, Ill. | 9/18/21 | def. Jackson in handicap; Rogers no-shows |
| Flash Flanagan & Jayson Breed | East Carondelet, Ill. | 10/16/21 | def. Kasa in handicap; Hargas injured |
| Shawn Santel & Mauler McDarby | East Carondelet, Ill. | 2/13/22 | |
| VACANT | East Carondelet, Ill. | 3/13/22 | announced on webshow; Santel injured |
| Gil Rogers & Billy McNeil | East Carondelet, Ill. | 3/13/22 | def. McDarby & Sean Vincent |
| VACANT | 5/15/2022 | announced on webshow; Rogers injured | |
| Kowalski & Mauler McDarby | East Carondelet, Ill. | 8/14/22 | def. Gary Jackson & Billy McNeil in tournament final |
| Gary Jackson & The Big Texan | Belleville, Ill. | 10/1/22 | |
| Bradley Diggs & Lamonte Potts | Belleville, Ill. | 2/11/23 | impromptu challenge |
| Cowboy Bob Orton & Tony Atlas | East St. Louis, Ill. | 3/25/23 | |
| Bradley Diggs & Lamonte Potts | Belleville, Ill. | 7/8/23 | Flash Flanagan substituted for Atlas |
| Brandon Barretta & Joe Vinetti | Belleville, Ill. | 2/9/24 | No Disqualification |
| Bradley Diggs & Lamonte Potts | Saint Louis, Mo. | 5/18/24 | 2-1 in a best-of-three-falls match |
Credit: David Creahin
Saint Louis Wrestling 