WrestleMax STL’s tag title was determined in a three-way elimination match in 2023.
Three qualifying matches on October 29 saw Dan the Dad & Kaia McKenna, Eli Knight & Malik Bosede, and Kenway & SK Bishop defeated by those who advanced.
| WON BY | LOCATION | DATE | NOTES |
| Mike Outlaw & Camaro Jackson | Columbia, Ill. | 12/15/23 | def. GPA & Laynie Luck and Jake Bosche & Scott Stanley in a 3-way elimination tournament final |
| VACANT | 3/28/24 | Due to Outlaw suffering quadriceps tendon tear on 3/17 | |
| Jake Bosche & Scott Stanley | Columbia, Ill. | 4/26/24 | tables, ladders, and chairs match with Rahim De La Suede & Moses, Campbell Myers & SK Bishop, and Jabari King & ATM |
Saint Louis Wrestling 