Glory Pro Wrestling’s top prize is the Crown of Glory Championship. Jason Kincaid was crowned inaugural champ after last defeating Paco in a four-way elimination tournament final on February 19, 2017.
The one-night tournament at the first Glory Pro card saw Kobe Durst, Danny Adams, Curt Stallion, and Everett Connors knocked out during the first round.
| WON BY | LOCATION | DATE | NOTES |
| Jason Kincaid | Alton, Ill. | 2/19/17 | def. Paco, Ethan Page, and Shigehiro Irie in a 4-way elimination tournament final |
| Myron Reed | Alton, Ill. | 5/7/17 | |
| Jake Something | Alton, Ill. | 10/15/17 | |
| Curt Stallion | Collinsville, Ill. | 7/22/18 | |
| Eddie Kingston | Collinsville, Ill. | 6/2/19 | |
| VACANT | Collinsville, Ill. | 9/22/19 | Kingston unable to make second straight defense |
| AJ Gray | Collinsville, Ill. | 9/22/19 | def. Paco and Stallion in 3-way |
| VACANT | Saint Louis, Mo. | 5/22/21 | stripped for injury; cannot make title defense |
| Jake Something | Saint Louis, Mo. | 5/22/21 | def. Rohit Raju and Myron Reed in three-way |
| Mike Outlaw | Saint Louis, Mo. | 8/22/21 | Dog Collar match; beats Gray 2/6/22; also unifies Midwest Territory title 7/24/22 |
| Camaro Jackson | Saint Louis, Mo. | 9/25/22 | |
| Calvin Tankman | Saint Louis, Mo. | 6/24/23 | |
| Camaro Jackson | Saint Louis, Mo. | 11/19/23 | |
| Jake Something | Saint Louis, Mo. | 12/17/23 | 3-way w/ Warhorse |
| Warhorse | Saint Louis, Mo. | 12/30/23 | 2-1 in a Three Stages of Hell match (standard, tables, dog collar) |
Saint Louis Wrestling 