As 2011 rang in, Herb Simmons and Larry Matysik restructured SICW. No longer would they recognize the numerous titles in the MMWA-SICW alliance.
Until his death in 2018, Matysik insisted that the title be called “Classic Wrestling Championship” without the promotional prefix. Afterwards, the prefix was added. It is the highest honor in SICW.
| WON BY | LOCATION | DATE | NOTES |
| Danny Boy Hawkins | East Carondelet, Ill. | 1/22/11 | def. Brandon Espinosa in tournament final |
| Ron Powers | East Carondelet, Ill. | 3/26/11 | |
| Ricky Cruz | East Carondelet, Ill. | 5/19/12 | |
| Ken Kasa | East Carondelet, Ill. | 6/15/13 | impromptu challenge match |
| Heath Hatton | East Carondelet, Ill. | 7/26/14 | |
| Flash Flanagan | East Carondelet, Ill. | 11/15/14 | |
| Gary Jackson | East Carondelet, Ill. | 2/21/15 | |
| Flash Flanagan | East Carondelet, Ill. | 4/26/15 | |
| Kahagas | East Carondelet, Ill. | 12/12/15 | 3-way cage match w/Powers |
| Flash Flanagan | East Carondelet, Ill. | 1/16/16 | |
| VACANT | East Carondelet, Ill. | 4/15/16 | Flanagan relinquishes due to injury |
| Ron Powers | East Carondelet, Ill. | 4/15/16 | def. Kahagas in tournament final |
| VACANT | East Carondelet, Ill. | 1/21/17 | Powers retires |
| Chris Hargas | East Carondelet, Ill. | 5/20/17 | def. Flash Flanagan in 2/3 falls tournament final |
| Ken Kasa | East Carondelet, Ill. | 10/21/17 | |
| Marc Houston | East Carondelet, Ill. | 3/24/18 | |
| Flash Flanagan | East Carondelet, Ill. | 5/19/18 | steel cage match |
| Steve Fender | East Carondelet, Ill. | 10/20/18 | |
| Ricky Cruz | East Carondelet, Ill. | 5/25/19 | also holds MMWA title |
| Curtis Wylde | East Carondelet, Ill. | 9/21/19 | |
| Ricky Cruz | East Carondelet, Ill. | 12/28/19 | no-countout, no DQ; Cruz’s future shots vs. Wylde’s hair |
| VACANT | East Carondelet, Ill. | 7/21/21 | stripped due to schedule conflicts |
| Attila Khan | East Carondelet, Ill. | 8/21/21 | def. Flash Flanagan in tournament final as masked War Machine; unmasked 10/9/21 |
| Flash Flanagan | East Carondelet, Ill. | 5/14/22 | def. Khan & Travis Cook in handicap elimination match; Flanagan’s and Cook’s careers were on the line |
| Attila Khan | East Carondelet, Ill. | 7/9/22 | |
| The Big Texan | Saint Louis, Mo. | 5/13/23 | Texas Death match |
Saint Louis Wrestling 